History Response to Post Discussion History Essay Paper (Essay Sample)
Make Response to the Lead-Off Question and Answer
Instructor's Lead-Off Question: Discuss the following historical thesis: that New York was immune to the main characteristics of North Atlantic Trading System since that region's economy did not involve a slavery component.
Instructor's Lead-Off Response: When one examines the North Atlantic Trading System, a close analysis determines that the crux of that system was indeed slavery. What developed into the triangular trade patterns among Europe, Africa and the Americas, the key element was slavery and that collateral economic products such as rum, mollasses, sugar cane or tobacco was directly tied to slavery. For example, if one looks at the Chesapeake and Carolinas economies, agricultural production was based on labor-intensive crops such as tobacco or indigo that required a slave-driven plantation system. In New England, such an agricultural system did not exist. Farms were family-owned and operated, needing no slaves. New York farms did not require slaves since, unlike the southern plantations, did not operate as competitive entities; in fact they operated more as cooperatives given the role of the local Anglican and Dutch Reformed Churches. Furthermore, in terms of general morality, there was no tolerance for slavery. Other regional industries such as ship transportation required no slaves. Therefore, one can conclude that New York was immune to the slave practicing tendencies of the North Atlantic trading system given the region's unique economic and religious characteristics.
Response to Post
I read your post and I like how you developed the question and the thesis. A thesis should be specific and argumentative, providing the basis for discussion as well as balanced analysis of the subject. You brilliantly begin by giving the overview of the North Atlantic Trade, the countries that were involved in it and those that did not participate. In my view, that is an effective strategy because the reader can almost predict that New York, Which was in New England, was not a party to the trade agreement, hence was not affected by the slave economy. While England is in Europe, it had a secluded economy, one shaped by family-owned plantations and the values espoused by the Church of England. A good
You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to slavery:
- From the end of the Civil War into the early twentieth-century, was Reconstruction a success. . .Description: The reconstruction period can be termed as both a success and failure in trying to establish civil rights for African Americans. The black community was oppressed in many ways but at some point, there was reprieve for them....2 pages/≈550 words | APA | History | Essay |
- James Horn: Jamestown and the Forging of American democracyDescription: Horns speaks of two events with happened simultaneously and shaped American history altogether; A gathering of the general assembly and the arrival of a buttered privateer. It was carrying the first shipment of African slaves a few weeks later. According to his well-narrated account of the happening...5 pages/≈1375 words | MLA | History | Essay |
- Slavery during the constitutional convention History EssayDescription: The constitutional convention resulted in the various changes in the constitution, which would be followed by members from the northern and southern states. However, the process was not easy since compromises had to be done in an attempt to create a stable government. Such compromises focused ...2 pages/≈550 words | APA | History | Admission Essay |