Deductive-Arguments
This is just a short assignment designed to assess whether you're understanding the concept of deductive validity correctly. There are two questions to answer. In the first, you are asked to make a judgment about whether a stated argument is deductively valid. In the second, you are asked to construct a deductively valid argument. The second task is probably more difficult, but sit with it for awhile. I have faith that you can get it--or at least get close to it.
The first question concerns the following cartoon:
In the text-box provided below, please answer the following:
1) Is the penguin making a deductively valid argument? Why or why not? Try to be specific and explain using examples. If his thinking is not valid, then try to identify where the penguin is going wrong.
For the next question, consider this meme:
2) The creator of this meme is not making an explicit argument. There are no clearly written premises or a conclusion that could in principle be true or false. However an argument is being implied, and you must formulate this argument your head in order to understand and appreciate the meme. (Just as, in order to appreciate Jim's response to Dwight, you must take "False. Black bear." to mean something like "It is not true that the question at hand is a ridiculous question, because it has an answer. And questions that have answers are not ridiculous. And, moreover, the answer to the question is 'black bear.'") What I want you to do now is create a deductively valid argument with two premises and one conclusion that captures the logic of this Kirby meme. You should use either the modus ponens or modus tollens argument forms. (Modus tollens probably looks best.) To construct the argument, it may be easiest to work backward from the conclusion. That is, first ask yourself: What is the claim that the meme-maker is ultimately trying to get us to accept?
CRITICAL THINKING
Name
Course
Instructor Date
In the text-box provided below, please answer the following:1) Is the penguin making a deductively valid argument? Why or why not? Try to be specific and explain using examples. If his thinking is not valid, then try to identify where the penguin is going wrong.For the next question, consider this meme:
In deductive arguments one makes conclusions from generalizations and in logic, the conclusion of reasoning is included in the premises, while the approach starts from the general to the specific. An argument is valid deductively if the premises are true and the conclusion is true (Evans, 2015). “Penguins are black and white” is the major premise, “some old TV shows are black and white” is the minor premise and “therefore, some penguins are old TV shows” is the conclusion. This is not a deductively valid argument since the premises are true, but the conclusion is not true. Thus, the penguin is wrong for concluding that all penguins are old TV shows, since there are old TV shows that are not black and white and the TV shows are inanimate unlike animals. An example is, premise 1: All U.S. first ladies are born in the U.S. Premise 2: Melania Trump is the first lady, conclusion: So Melania Trump was born in the U.S. premise 1 and the conclusion are not true and so is the validity of the argument.
2) The creator of this meme is not making an explicit argument. There are no clearly written premises or a conclusion that could in principle be true or false. However an argument is being implied, and you must formulate this argument yo...
π Other Visitors are Viewing These APA Essay Samples:
- Mau, Jewish Family Survived The Holocaust 4 pages/β1100 words | 3 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Child Abuse Identification Paper. Physical Abuse. Child Sexual Abuse5 pages/β1375 words | 3 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- PHIL101 The Meaning of Life. Evaluate the Argument and Apply to Life. 1 page/β275 words | 2 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- The Glass Menagerie and August Research Assignment2 pages/β550 words | 5 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Drug Addiction: A Social Problem2 pages/β550 words | 2 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Brain and Language Relationship in case of Second Level Language1 page/β550 words | 1 Source | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Competitive Advantage Action Plan: The Wal-Mart Lending Plan2 pages/β550 words | 3 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |