Suspect Quebec Mosque Terror Attack Was of Moroccan Origin (Essay Sample)
write " Post Hoc Fallacy " passage analysis essay about
Suspect in Quebec mosque terror attack was of Moroccan origin.
This assignment requires you to find a passage, that contains poor argument(s),
in the media (e.g. newspaper, blog post). Your task is to present a detailed
analysis of that passage.
write-up of your analysis, you should indicate:
What’s the passage about? What’s the author’s main conclusion?
Which premises are you focusing on? Sometimes a long passage has many
premises, but your analysis can focus on premises that relate to a fallacy, for
What fallacy exists in the passage? Explain how that fallacy is an example of
Connect the weak argument to principles of argumentation. Which principle
was obviously violated? Which principle could the author follow to make a
better argument in the future?
Are there any other course concepts that help you build a strong analysis
about this passage? (e.g. objectivity, a conflict style, etc.).
Is it possible to make this argument strong? How? What would a better
argument look like?
Depending on the fallacy, principle(s), and other course concepts you discuss,
bring in the appropriate vocabulary Some vocabulary that can help your analysis: argument, premise, conclusion,
fallacious, weak, strong, questionable (plus, the vocabulary that is relevant to
your fallacy and principle(s)).
Principle of Charity
Principle of Fallibility
Burden of Proof
written analysis should be approximately 3 pages double-spaced
(Times New Roman, 12 point font).
For your Bibliography, follow the MLA guide
12 February 2017
Suspect in Quebec Mosque Terror was of Moroccan Origin
In the article there were statements made that proves their initial speculations are wrong because they were quick to judge the attacker to be either Muslim or Moroccan. According to this line in the article: “But these assertions are utterly false. The suspect is neither Moroccan nor Muslim. The Moroccan individual, Mohamed Belkhadir, was actually one of the worshippers at the mosque and called 911 to summon the police, playing no role whatsoever in the shooting.” This only goes to show that immigrants are suspected to be the ones who have the highest tendency to commit a crime. This is false news because the actual shooter is a white French Canadian, 27 years old and his name is Alexandre Bissonnette. Based on his appearance, he is an anti-immigrant nationalist. It was Francois Deschamps who told the local newspaper that he was able to identify the terrorist based on the photo shown to him.
In order to avoid deception, one must know how to spot fake news. Before believing something, read past headlines from the new provider. Check what site it is from, the date and the time, and the author – check if he or she is reliable. Fake news will use links and sources that are not credible so it is important to consider these. If the news has photos, question where they came from and also the quotations in the article. According to Robins-Early, search for the news on reliable websites and see it they have it. It is almost impossible for them not to cover real news. Before sharing the news, think about it and be sure it is real (2016).
The Fallibility principle is being violated here and those who suspected the shooter to be an immigrant should be aware that they could be wrong. When this happens, the person who is in the best situation will let argument’s strength determine which one is substantial. In case none of the arguments could not be supported, the stronger argument has to be determined.
The strong argument here...
- Barriers for Women in Stem: Stereotype ThreatDescription: The response is our beliefs, acting in different forms ranging from elusive stereotyping and embedded bias to deliberate illiteracy and blatant discrimination...2 pages/≈550 words | No Sources | MLA | Social Sciences | Essay |
- Japanese Philosophy Description: The Samurai were the warriors during the pre-modern Japan. Later, they became the ruling military class which eventually developed to be the highest ranking social caste in the Edo period...8 pages/≈2200 words | No Sources | MLA | Social Sciences | Essay |
- Whole Earth FestivalDescription: The mixer of the different arts, music, foods and the food courts from the different cultures and times in America is thrilling and largely authentic...2 pages/≈550 words | No Sources | MLA | Social Sciences | Essay |