Pros and Cons of Lifetime Appointment for Supreme Court

Article III of the U.S. Constitution Essay
Student’s Name
College/University
Course
Professor’s Name
Due Date
Article III of the U.S. Constitution indicates that the country’s judicial power is anchored on a single supreme court and other lower-level courts as may be established by the Congress. The supreme and lower-level judges are expected to demonstrate good behavior and receive adequate compensation during their tenure. In this vein, federal judges hold office for life. This paper delineates the pros and cons of lifetime Supreme Court appointments and the rationales for why judges should have term limits.
Pros of Lifetime Appointment for Supreme Court
Lifetime appointments for Supreme Court judges ensure judicial independence preservation. This independence is one of the significant advantages since it insulates justices from the requirement to seek reappointment and political pressure. This insulation harbors them from making partial and non-principled decisions due to fear of public opinion and reprisal. Consequently, it ensures that the judiciary maintains its integrity as a coequal and distinct arm of government. Expertise and experience accumulation of justice over time is another advantage of a lifetime appointment. Such appointments enable supreme court judges to develop a comprehensive understanding of the Constitution, law, and legal complexities. Also, it ensures partisanship where the courts remain insulated and entirely immune (Doerfler & Moyn, 2021). Therefore, the experience provides nuanced and informed decision-making, fostering stability and consistency in interpreting and applying the law.
Cons of Lifetime Appointment for Supreme Court
Lifetime appointments for supreme court judges have a vital drawback in that judges are allowed to work in court long after a decrease in their abilities. As the justices age, they may find it challenging to stay updated with technological and societal advancements. Therefore, their decisions may not address emerging issues and reflect contemporary societal values. Moreover, lifetime ap...