Reproduce A Published Experiment: Problem, Study Accomplishments (Article Critique Sample)
Instructions:Reproduce a Published Experiment:Part A)Imagine you are a junior researcher at a world-renowned, high-tech laboratory. The senior scientist asks that you critique and replicate an experiment within the software defined networking, mobile computing, or Internet of Things domain to demonstrate your research and technical prowess to the group. They have not specified which experiment to analyze; however, they stipulate that it must be found within a peer-reviewed publication within the last ten years and ask that you produce a short report presenting your critique and experience replicating the experiment.First, locate a research study that contains a reproducible experiment taking the time and resource constraints of the course into consideration.Second, analyze the original study and address the items described below:• Describe the problem addressed. Why is it important? Is this an agreed-upon problem?• Describe what was accomplished by the study. What was not achieved?• Describe the methodology the study utilized. Was it appropriate? Justify.• Describe the study results and the contribution it made to the body of knowledge, if any.• Describe possible extensions to the research, if any. In what ways can the study be enhanced or modified to provide additional value? Discuss any limitations or assumptions held within the study and how they can be addressed.• Present the study’s experiment that will be reproduced. Be sure to outline the setup and resources utilized.• Describe how you will reproduce the experiment. How does your experiment differ from the original? In what ways were they the same? How do your results compare with the original results, and what conclusions can be drawn with the additional data provided by your experiment?• Finally, reproduce the experiment and document the setup, procedure, and results. Create any tables, graphs, raw results, or aggregate reports that would allow for direct comparison with the original study.Ensure that your critique is comprehensive and meets the quality expectations of doctoral-level work.References: Included a minimum of five scholarly resourcesLength: 5-7 pages, not include title and reference pages Part B)Very frequently, new research and ideas are presented in the form of posters. This serves as a way for the presenter to both convey their idea, but importantly receive feedback as well. Your next task for the week is to create a poster presenting your idea. Begin by reviewing this week’s resources on how to create a poster and be sure to follow the guidelines as discussed in these resources. You should then record a brief (2-5 minute) recording of you presenting your idea using your poster.Submit your original study (in PDF format), your critique, experiment outputs, poster, and screencast, by clicking the Submit to Dropbox button.
Reproduce a Published Experiment
In the article by Stajkic et al (2016), the researchers sought to determine whether a downscaled testbed was effective in real deployment of networks of applications for running protocols and the Internet of Things (IoT). Running tests for (IoT) applications requires both financial and human resources to mimic the real world, even while there is reduced time for experiments. When there is a choice between simulation and testbeds, it is potentially challenging to assess the better choice to determine how developments will work. However, for the testbeds, there is evaluation including using the relevant hardware devices to achieve this, and this includes the routers and switches. For the experiments, this is important to test the applications and the real systems. The lack of scalable network testbeds affects the ability of researchers testing how applications can work in real life deployments.
The researchers successfully tested the downscaled testbed to be used for the real deployment, and using the suggested methodology, they compared the results of network throughput and typologies (Stajkic et al., 2016). Since there is a need to identify practical solutions to experimentation testbeds, the downscaled option is conceivable as the large scale operations require resources and are not feasible in certain situations. The study was able to show that the proposed downscaling procedure was effective to produce results that would be deployed in the real world. This is more reliant than depending on simplifying the system requirements as this affects the reliability of experimental results when considering real life deployment.
Testbed experimentation has been used in place of simulation and modeling because option mimics reality deployments in network research (Lent & Gelenbe, 2013). The proposed methodology was
- Productivity Spillovers In Team Production Article CritiqueDescription: Select an article relevant to this week’s topic of team production and performance. Research, critique and discuss this article in the light of our topic. ...2 pages/≈550 words | 2 Sources | APA | Management | Article Critique |
- Examine and Critique a Scholarly Article Related to Mobile Computing ChallengesDescription: The authors, therefore explore various ways through which two of the domains: technology and organization act to make the design of business models successful within the mobile service industry....3 pages/≈825 words | 4 Sources | APA | Management | Article Critique |
- Review, Critique Reflection Article About TransportationDescription: Critique reflection of literature evaluation, including best practices that can be applied to improve the management of the transportation function. ...1 page/≈275 words | 1 Source | APA | Management | Article Critique |