Questions Response: The Norcross argument
Please read Alastair Norcross: "Puppies, Pigs, and People: Eating Meat and Marginal Cases" and answer prompt a and b.
Theres no need to compose this as an essay, instead just answer the question.
So, in "Puppies, Pigs, and People: Eating Meat and Marginal Cases", Alastair Norcross argues that the problem of marginal cases is a serious problem we must confront. In effect, the problem of marginal cases says the following: Whatever kind and level of rationality that is required for full moral status that excludes animals, there will be some humans who fail to have that status. These "marginal cases" will include infants and small children, temporarily cognitively-impaired adults, and permanently cognitively-impaired adults. If we claim that differences in rationality means that animals do not have full moral standing, we have to say that the same is true of infants, and the cognitively impaired. Norcross argues that what these marginal cases show is that if a subject fails to be morally evaluable, it does not mean that we can treat him or her any way we choose. The reason why is that even if such subjects cannot reason, they can still suffer. (Notice how this puts Norcross squarely within a Utilitarian and not a Kantian camp.)
(a) Do you think Norcross's argument holds up? Why or why not?
(b) If Norcross's argument holds up, is there any way of supporting a large meat-eating culture that does not cause large amounts of suffering to animals? (Assume here that free-range and cage-less farming cause less suffering than factory farms, but they do not eliminate it completely.)
π Other Visitors are Viewing These MLA Essay Samples:
- History essay. Kenneth Cavander. Love and Death in Ancient Greece. Article 122 pages/β550 words | 2 Sources | MLA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- World War 2's effect on women in the workplace US/Britain7 pages/β1925 words | 3 Sources | MLA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Position Argument5 pages/β1375 words | 5 Sources | MLA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Analyze how Cool Hand Luke employs both the Myth of Sisyphus1 page/β275 words | No Sources | MLA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- The Frankenstein Application Essay3 pages/β825 words | 4 Sources | MLA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Write an Analytical Paper on Naked by China Forbes4 pages/β1100 words | No Sources | MLA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Discussion Assignment on Adventures of Huckleberry Finn1 page/β275 words | No Sources | MLA | Literature & Language | Essay |