Sign In
Not register? Register Now!
Pages:
2 pages/≈550 words
Sources:
Check Instructions
Style:
APA
Subject:
Social Sciences
Type:
Essay
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 8.64
Topic:

Critique on Thomson’s Philosophy on Abortion

Essay Instructions:

See the attached files for instructions
Check the argument summary you wrote previously for Thomson's Philosophy on abortion (Order #00154251).
I've also attached the readings just in case you need to read them again.
Let me know if you have any questions.

Response Paper 2 Topic: Abortion The goal of your Response Paper is to either: 1. Critique the reading or; 2. Defend the reading from a critique. Critiquing the reading involves finding something about the reading that you think is incorrect or not entirely accurate and explaining why it is incorrect or not entirely accurate, along with providing the implications of that incorrectness or inaccuracy. Defending the reading from a critique means that there is a popular or existing critique of the reading that you think is misguided, unfair, or otherwise incorrect. Your job in this case is to explain why that critique is misguided, unfair, or otherwise wrong, and defend the author’s position. Do not include any summary of the philosopher’s article. Focus solely on your own, individual, original thought and argumentation. Word Count There is a maximum word count of 500 words for each Argument Summary. A good rule of thumb is not to be under or over by more than 10% of the stated word count. I will stop reading after 10% over the stated word count has been reached. Footnotes are not permitted. Citations Citations are necessary for this assignment, even if you only use the textbook. When citing the textbook, use the format (Author Last Name, page #). So if I were referencing Lukianoff and Haidt’s reading on page 183, my in-text citation would be (Lukianoff and Haidt, 183). You would then use APA format to create a proper bibliographic entry. Use APA Citation Format Outside sources are not required or expected for this assignment and they may not earn you higher marks. They might actually decrease your mark. However, if you are determined to use outside sources, you must cite in APA format.

Essay Sample Content Preview:

Critique on Thomson’s Philosophy on Abortion
Student's Name
University Affiliation
Professor's Name
Course Title
Due Date
Critique on Thomson’s Philosophy on Abortion
There are several incoherencies and inconsistencies in Thomson’s defense for abortion. First, Thomson makes a comparison between a newly fertilized ovum and the acorn of an oak tree (Thomson, 435). Although used in the preamble, Thomson uses this comparison to lay a foundation for her defense. Although it is just an example, it appears inconsistent since the fertilized ovum is a prelude to human life. The acorn of an oak represents an item whose well-being does not significantly concern society as a fertilized ovum would. The sanctity of human life is mainly derived from the fact that humans are the only social animals endowed with the ability to think. Due to the rational nature of human beings, their life in any form is incomparable to that of other forms of life. Biological evidence shows that a newly fertilized ovum starts multiplying rapidly due to the process of cell division. Subsequently, there is a huge difference between a fertilized ovum and an acorn of an oak tree. Therefore, the comparison between an ovum and an acorn of an oak tree significantly fails to appreciate the unique and rational nature of the human form of life.
Thomson also argues that a woman should not be obligated to carry a pregnancy where such pregnancy occurred against their wish. A good example...
Updated on
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to abortion:

HIRE A WRITER FROM $11.95 / PAGE
ORDER WITH 15% DISCOUNT!