Vernonia School District v. Acton Assignment

CASE BRIEF: VERNONIA SCHOOL DISTRICT V. ACTON ASSIGNMENT
Student Name
1. No, the Fourth Amendment was not intended to cover searches of students in public schools. The Supreme Court applied Fourth Amendment principles to school searches. It has recognized the need to balance students' privacy interests against the school's security in maintaining a safe and orderly learning environment. The Amendment was aimed at protecting citizens from unreasonable searches. Its discussion showed that the citizens have the right to security and their belongings. In this case, no searches should be carried out, and in case of one, a warrant should be issued with probable cause and supported by an oath that designates the area to be investigated and the things or persons to be held (Vernon School District v. Acton, 1995). Looking at students in public schools, the Court recognized that the learners have a reasonable expectation of privacy. Still, the expectation is reduced due to the school's role of maintaining an orderly and safe learning environment. The Supreme Court stated that random drug testing of student-athletes did not violate the Amendment because the search was reasonable where the school had the role of preventing drug use among student-athletes. It is because these students are seen as role models in the school society.
2. Society usually views talented individuals as role models among children. In some cases, role models are good examples, but regarding molarity and integrity, qualified athletes can be considered role models for children. These athletes are considered heroes in the community because they have attained huge successes through hard work, dedication, and discipline. The athletes' deeds can inspire children, thus making them strive for excellence and to grow a strong work ethic. Many professional athletes are not involved in scandals and controversies that may raise serious questions concerning their characters and morals. Society should recognize that professional athletes are experts who excel at their sport as they have the knowledge to guide complex ethical issues (Piccolo, 2020). Children should look up to trusted professionals with good morals and ethics. Children need guidance from recommended individuals because professional athletes are admirable for their dedication and hard work and who can help them develop a strong moral compass that will serve them well throughout their lives.
3. I agree with the Court's justification because the random drug-testing policy was reasonable under the Fourth Amendment. Society is experiencing a high rise in drug use among the youths, and as a result, schools would be required to carry out drug tests among the learners. It's also important for student-athletes to regularly submit to drug testing as a condition of participation in school athletics. The case was set after the school district passed the rule of drug-testing policy for st...