Common Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Symptoms during Covid-19
PHI 30 Peer Review Questionnaire
Paper author’s name:
Peer reviewer’s name
Introduction
Please identify the thesis of the paper:
How clearly is the thesis stated? Did you have any problems understanding it?
Background Section
Does the author explain all relevant technical concepts?
If not, what is not explained?
Does the author explain the relevant background in a clear way?
What could use more explanation?
Original Argument Section
Does the author make their own argument in this paper? If so, where is it located (page numbers)?
Do you feel the author makes it very clear the point they are trying to make or do you feel that the author could work on making their argument a bit clearer?
Were you persuaded by the argument?
Suggestions for changes?
Response Section
Did the author charitably consider how someone who disagreed with them could respond? Or is it a bit implausible someone would have responded in that way?
Was it clear what the author’s rebuttal to that response was?
General Feedback
Were there any places where you felt the paper digressed from its main aims? (Page numbers)
Was the paper easy to read or could it have used some revising for grammar and spelling?
What do you like most about the paper?
What do you think needs more work?
Any additional feedback:
Peer Review
Name
Course Code, Course Name
Department, University
Tutor
PHI 30 Peer Review Questionnaire
Paper author’s name:
Peer reviewer’s name:
Introduction
Please identify the thesis of the paper:
Participants in the study showed symptoms of PTSD with the events that had not happened or ones that had been directly or indirectly exposed to COVID-19.
How clearly is the thesis stated? Did you have any problems understanding it?
The thesis is well stated. First, it is clear and well stated. Second, the thesis is arguable and if read by experts, they can either agree or dismiss it. Again, it reflects on the author’s position on the topic that indeed PTSD happened during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Background Section
Does the author explain all relevant technical concepts?
The author has given an elaborate overview of the technical concepts available in the paper. For instance, takes us through the participants of the research and how they were recruited online and the events they had been exposed to either directly or indirectly. In addition, the writer states that no wishing or false reality was mentioned in the paper to mean that there was legitimate empirical data as well as evidence. However, it had some shortcomings.
If not, what is not explained?
There were limitations in the research process since the whole project did not incorporate a more diverse and distributed set of data. The research should not have been conducted only on a set of individuals being that the pandemic affected nearly everyone in the world. That the research targeted a specific group doesn’t make it quite convincing.
Does the author explain the relevant background in a clear way?
The author clearly explains the background. For example, the research focused on three important models, including pre, present, and post-traumatic dimensions. Also, the research mentions the number of surveyed population.
What could use more explanation?
The research did not however elaborate on the gender of the population targeted. In t...
You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to stress:
- Moral Distress Encounter Essay1 page/≈275 words | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Essay |
- Clinical Problem: Moral Distress1 page/≈275 words | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Coursework |
- Stress Experience in Women2 pages/≈550 words | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- The Stress Impact on Children and Family of The Flint Water Crisis4 pages/≈1100 words | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Essay |
- Developing Stress Management Training for Employees2 pages/≈550 words | Other | Business & Marketing | Coursework |
- Stress Appraisal Psychology Essay Research Coursework1 page/≈275 words | APA | Psychology | Essay |
- Caregiving Stress1 page/≈275 words | APA | Psychology | Essay |