Sign In
Not register? Register Now!
Pages:
6 pages/≈1650 words
Sources:
Check Instructions
Style:
APA
Subject:
Social Sciences
Type:
Essay
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 25.92
Topic:

Assignment Social Sciences Essay Research Coursework

Essay Instructions:

There are two questions, each question write 3 pages and each question should provide citations and works cited page where necessary.
The required readings are in the attachments, pleases use your own words.
1) State building is the most difficult type of conflict management. According to Wimmer, what are the main aspects to state building, and what are its positive consequences? Dobbins and Miller find that post-Cold War state-building missions are usually successful. Provide some examples of this. According to these authors, which factors promote successful state building? Do you believe that state building efforts generally do more good or more harm? Explain.
2) According to Kolenda, U.S. generals are out of ideas in Afghanistan. What were the key lessons from the RAND study on insurgency wars? How does this relate to the current problems in Afghanistan? Malkasian identifies obstacles to success for Afghan state building. Discuss in detail, Afghan corruption, Pakistani meddling, and Afghan resistance to occupation as three of those obstacles. Do you believe that the U.S. and its allies should withdraw from Afghanistan soon? Why or why not?


1)   State building is the most difficult type of conflict management. According to Wimmer, what are the main aspects to state building, and what are its positive consequences?     Dobbins and Miller find that post-Cold War state-building missions are usually successful.  Provide some examples of this. According to these authors, which factors promote successful state building? Do you believe that state building efforts generally do more good or more harm? Explain.

2)   According to Kolenda, U.S. generals are out of ideas in Afghanistan. What were the key lessons from the RAND study on insurgency wars?  How does this relate to the current problems in Afghanistan?  Malkasian identifies obstacles to success for Afghan state   building. Discuss in detail, Afghan corruption, Pakistani meddling, and Afghan resistance to occupation as three of those obstacles.  Do you believe that the U.S. and its allies should withdraw from Afghanistan soon?  Why or why not?


Essay Sample Content Preview:

State Building
Name
Institutional Affiliation
State Building
Question 1
Wimmer (2018) offers an avid analysis on state building and its facets. He asserts that there are two main aspects of state building, which are the political-integration and political-identity aspects. The former refers to the ability of extending “political alliances across the terrain of a country” while the latter connotes to “the emergence of a sense of loyalty to and identification with the institutions of the state, independent of who currently governs (p. 152).” In essence, these two guidelines offer the founding elements for any robust and stable country because first, every ethnic divide is recognized. In doing this, the state creates a bridge instead of an ever-widening gap of maintaining close contacts with its citizens. When the government forms various avenues such as political organizations where its nationals are the members, citizens feel as though they are at the center of power regardless of whether their political party is the occupant of the seats of government. It is this scenario that guarantees the country’s intellectuals, political elites and ordinary citizens will define that national community that is bound to be inclusive. Every person receives equal treatment regardless of their ethnic or racial background.
From an overall perspective, national building can be deemed to be an activity with massive positive consequences. In this regard, national building creates a platform in which people establish a substantial policy that is progressive to the economy. This procedure is possible because crosscutting alliances alleviates zero-sum game where one ethnic group, the one in the government, is the winner the others are losers as they struggle for control. Besides, people elicit the true sense of patriotism as inclusivity fosters an elevated sense of ownership of the state. Consequently, this feeling transcends narcissism that is predicated on one’s profession, clan, village, or family. It is the resulting loyalty to the nation that makes inclusionary countries a pleasing place to be for its nationals. According to Wimmer (2018, p. 153), this shared identity eclipses “even the best crafted of propaganda mechanism.” On the other hand, the nation has much to gain too. Such people are open to paying their taxes and even better, they are less resistant to supporting a welfare state. Even better, these people are recipients of effective and efficient manner of governing from their states. In situations where the country has minorities and majorities, inclusive coalitions guarantee that they are less likely to engage in civil war and in retrospect, they promote economic growth.
State building missions that have been conducted in post-Cold War period have been relatively successful. This assertion is apparent in that “16 have produced greater peace, 18 saw increases in democratization, 17 saw improvement in government effectiveness, 18 experienced economic growth… and 18 saw improvements in their human development... (Dobbins & Miller, 2013).” The examples of countries that could fall in any one of these categories include Namibia, Mozambique, Somalia, Sierra Le...
Updated on
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to civil war:

HIRE A WRITER FROM $11.95 / PAGE
ORDER WITH 15% DISCOUNT!