Sign In
Not register? Register Now!
Pages:
1 page/≈275 words
Sources:
6 Sources
Style:
APA
Subject:
Social Sciences
Type:
Essay
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 4.32
Topic:

Al Qaeda, FBI, and Michael Collins

Essay Instructions:

Comment on 2 postings as if you were talking in my voice. 100 words and 3 sources each:
Joseph 
Discussion 8
1. Yes, it seems that prior to 9/11, terror attacks did not spark such response as 9/11 did. I think because of the massive loss of life, primarily Americans, but as mentioned numerous other foreign nationals, this was complete justification for coalition forces to enter Afghanistan to route out bin Laden. I think Muslim countries, especially had a say in the matter. From the reading, many were horrified and even showed contempt for bin Laden following one attack with such a massive loss of life, especially against civilians and Muslims. However, off the top of my head, I don't believe there was ever any large contingency of direct military support for the invasion of Afghanistan other than use of airspace and airbases. The majority of the coalition was American, Canadian, British and German with mostly European nations involved.
2. I would say so yes, that and to prevent fear of flying, a sizeable economic chunk for the US as well as abroad. I think officials did not believe it was possible, speculation leads me to believe, the training required to fly a plane and how would one actually hijack it. However, as history has shown, both are doable. Whereas on the economic side, it would potentially have been a disaster if people stopped flying. It would wreak havoc on the travel industry as well as the business and hospitality industries among others. I don't think we realize how interconnected the world is.
3. I think calling Collins O'Neil's hero is both intellectually dishonest and ethically inconsistent. I think a man like O'Niell could say he admired Collins, but not be considered a hero. Collins essentially goes against almost everything O'Neill is fighting against, maybe save being a nationalist or arguably a martyr, or even being betrayed by his own. The latter are realy the only way I can see O'Neill to have reconciled his role as FBI and still hold Collins in high regard. The IRA had committed numerous atrocities in the name of independence, however we can argue the American Revolutionaries did as well, so its a bit of a paradox. I
Katherine 
Week 8 Discussion
1. Yes, I do think that the wide range of victims gave countries justification to fight. Many countries at that time had not been impacted by radical Islamic terrorism and while they may have acknowledged al Qaeda as a threat, they may not have been able to legitimize contributing resources to stopping them. Once such a drastic attack was perpetrated against the United States, allies, especially NATO allies, as 9/11 could be seen as an act of war, felt compelled to help us fight. This could also have been the tipping point for Muslim countries, since verse 5:32 in the Koran states how the killing of even one innocent person kills all mankind. All of the innocent lives lost on 9/11 may have given the Muslim countries the justification that al Qaeda does not believe in the Koran in the same way they do, regarding protecting life.
2. My research paper actually talks about this topic pretty extensively. Prior to 9/11, it was assumed that a hijacker would make demands to authorities over the cockpit radio and land the plane. Hijackers typically held some hostages until their demands were met, but most are released unharmed. The last time an airplane itself had been used as a missile was during World War 2 with the kamikaze pilots. The same page (The Looming Tower, page 396) states that the idea already in the subconscious of members of the FBI. I think some people were concerned with avoiding a panic at the bureau and didn't want to acknowledge that the concerns about terrorist hijacking passenger airlines may be warranted.
3. As far as O'Neill's high regard for Michael Collins, I think we need to see the difference between the IRA when Collins formed it and the IRA that most of us think of. Collins' IRA was formed from men who refused to enlist in the British Army during WWI, then became the Irish army during the Irish war for independence. the guerrilla warfare performed by the IRA was done during wartime against and enemy they were at war with. I think the fact that O'Neill participated in operations against the IRA while he was an FBI agent shows that he didn't have a high regard for the current IRA. Considering Collins supported the treaty with Britain, i'm sure O'Neill believed that the IRA he was working against was not the one that Collins formed.

Essay Sample Content Preview:
Comments on Joseph Work
  1. I don’t believe that the massive response from various countries after the 9/11 attack was due to the “massive loss of life”. There are many more people dying every day in Africa due to lack of proper sanitation and inadequate food. I believe that people held contempt for bin Laden and the Al Qaeda because they managed to do the unthinkable – to create havoc in the center of the world’s most powerful country. If the United States could be attacked in broad day light like this, then no country was safe. Being a part of the War on Terror meant security for countries who did not share the same beliefs as the Al Qaeda (Shah, 2013).
  2. Though his response is confusing, I think I agree with his response that the authorities could not suspend flights because they would only cause panic when they are not yet sure whether the attack would happen or not. Also, cancelling all flights to and from the city meant the isolation of the hundreds of thousands of workers there – a situation that could actually lead wild speculation and possibly, distrust of the government’s capacity to ensure their safety (which also explains why the United States could not sit idly by after the attacks – they had to show their force in order to regain its citizen’s trust following the massive death toll) (Sperry, 2014).
  3. I agree with Mr. Connor here. Perhaps one may say that O’Neill admired Collins, but the latter cannot be called the latter’s “hero” mainly because O’Neill did not at all show guilt for what he did (McGreevy & Collins, 2014). In fact, O’Neill probably looked at Collins as an enemy – a hindrance that had to be overcome.
Comments on Katherine work
  1. Countries were moved to fight against the Al Qaeda not just because the 9/11 attacks had a wide range of victims. Instead, it was the daring of these terrorist groups to attack the United States – the center of the world’s power – in broad day light. Prior to the 9/11 people believed that terrorist op...
Updated on
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to world war 1:

HIRE A WRITER FROM $11.95 / PAGE
ORDER WITH 15% DISCOUNT!