Sign In
Not register? Register Now!
Essay Available:
2 pages/≈550 words
Check Instructions
Health, Medicine, Nursing
English (U.S.)
MS Word
Total cost:
$ 8.64

Ethical Dilemma Baby Boy Doe Health, Medicine, Nursing Essay (Essay Sample)


Examine the case of Baby Boy Doe (Darr, 2011, p. 16.) The objective of this assignment is to get you to think critically about real-life ethical dilemmas and the moral principals involved. There is no right or wrong answer, just try to look at this case subjectively. Most of the time, resolving ethical dilemmas is not so "black and white." Discuss arguments for and against the issues below
1. Discuss what makes this an ethical dilemma (read pp. 3 and 4).
2. Discuss the implications of this study in terms of the moral principles described in chapter 1.
Here are some questions that may guide your thinking:
Respect for persons: Did the hospital/ physicians allow the parents to be autonomous in their decision-making? Do you see any elements of paternalism on behalf of the physicians?
Beneficence: Did the hospital/ physicians act beneficently?
Nonmaleficence: Did the hospital/ physicians consider nonmaleficence?
Justice: Did the hospital act in a just way?
Reference: Darr, K. (2011). Ethics in Health Services Management. (5th Edition). Baltimore, MD: Health Professions Press, Inc.
APA format and 3 references


Ethical Dilemma Baby Boy Doe
Student’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
Ethical Dilemma Baby Boy Doe
In medical practice, cases of ethical dilemmas are frequent. On various occasions, health professionals undergo difficulties marked by a clash of individual rights, societal expectations, legal regulations, expected therapeutic interventions, personal perceptions, and institutional practices. The mix of these conflicting factors presents fertile grounds for ethical dilemmas. Baby Boy Doe case is an example of a moral dilemma. This dilemma reflects an ethical situation of whether or not to treat a child with disabilities. The case presents thought-provoking decisions and options to ponder about. Is it necessary to medically intervene in children with disabilities considering the cost implications and overall burden to the family and society? Does the child with disabilities have inalienable rights regarding access to life-saving health interventions?
In some instances, children born with disabilities have been denied life-saving interventions like surgeries. The decision to refuse treatment has been arrived at by the child’s parents or in conjunction with doctors while citing cost implications and emotional trouble associated with treatment and raising of such a child. The Indiana Baby Doe was born in Indiana with Down syndrome and a tracheoesophageal fistula. The upper section of Baby Doe’s esophagus lacks adequate continuity to the lower part (Darr,2011). The surgery was the primary intervention that demonstrated the significant potential for success. In the absence of treatment, the prognosis is of Baby Doe’s life was extremely poor. The doctor advised the parents against offering care to Baby Boy Doe due to perceived poor prognosis associated with Down syndrome. 

Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to ethical dilemma:

  • Assignment 4. Moral Approaches for I Am Mother Dilemma.
    Description: In the 2019 film, I Am Mother, the dilemma of choosing between the five patients vs. one puts a doctor in an awkward position. In the perspective of consequential moral reasoning, saving more lives is the best result....
    2 pages/≈550 words | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
  • In this scene, Mother presents an ethical dilemma to Daughter.
    Description: Consequentiality theory suggests that something is wrong or right, depending on the consequences after that. In most cases, people would consider lying to be wrong but in this case, when lying is helpful, then it is the right thing to do. ...
    2 pages/≈550 words | MLA | Communications & Media | Essay |
  • Moral Dilemma In Your Life
    Description: Describe a moral dilemma in your life and explain what each philosopher would say to you about it. Argue for the position that you think is philosophically the best. “Philosophically the best” means according to reason, and not according to how you were raised, which theory you understood the best....
    6 pages/≈1650 words | MLA | Social Sciences | Essay |