This is a free essay sample available for all students. If you are looking where to buy pre written essays on the topic “Black Lives Matter vs All Lives Matter”, browse our private essay samples.
In the wake of the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, the debate Black Lives Matter vs. All Lives Matter is back in the news. According to many people in the African American community, the slogan “All Lives Matter” is not an appeal to inclusion; however, it is a rebuke against the Black Lives Matter movement.
However, those who support All Lives Matter insist their slogan is about color blindness and diversity. All Lives Matter (ALM) debate has become a major subject of discussion and caused conflict between families and friends. This article offers an overview of the background and the striking resemblance to the current debate.
Are you exhausted? Do you need someone to write a well-crafted essay for you? Let EssayZoo take your worries away. We will write an awesome essay for you while you sit back and relax.
What Does Black Lives Matter Mean?
Black Lives Matter is an expression, but it is also the hashtag used to draw attention to blacks’ discrimination, racism, and inequity. The BLM movement is a struggle to eradicate white supremacy, racial profiling, and white privilege.
Its popularity has increased in the US following the high-profile cases of police brutality. However, it is also utilized in the UK as well as elsewhere. It is also important to note that the black lives matter movement is not limited to African Americans. Instead, it has become a global narrative against systemic racism and racial bias, faced by other races as well.
They point out that blacks are less likely to be killed by police officers in the US. And they claim they are also subject to discrimination in the US and other nations; they face discrimination. They would like to take action to combat inequality and injustice that stretches back to the time of slavery and which persists to this day.
All Life Matters Means
“All lives matter” was initially a response to “black lives count” in 2014, as per an article published in Congressional Quarterly, after the murder of two NYPD officers. The phrase was derived from “blue lives matter.” Joseph Margulies is an associate professor of law and politics at Cornell University. And he recently published the following article on the subject. Margulies says “all lives matter” is a slogan that strips “black lives are important” from its roots and then neuters it.
The proponents of this narrative claim that they want all lives to be treated equally. Should only black lives be protected?
What Has Happened to Black Lives Matter’s Growth?
The slogan was used widely following the murder of Trayvon Martin in Florida in the year 2012. Neighborhood monitor volunteer George Zimmerman shot the unarmed black teenager.
The support for police increased following other murders, such as Eric Garner. Who died from a chokehold, and Michael Brown, killed by an officer who claimed self-defense was his motive?
In the summer of 2020, George Floyd, a black male who was not armed, was shot dead. By an officer from the police force who laid his hands on his neck.
Protests with the hashtag #BLM were held across the globe as well as the hashtag #BlackLivesMatter was utilized on tens of thousands of millions of occasions.
In the UK the UK, anti-racism protests were attended by tens of hundreds of thousands.
Why “All Lives Matter” Is Insensitive and Unproductive
Let’s look at the phrase “Black lives matter.” It is a broad statement meant to emphasize the importance that lives have for blacks. And that black lives are important, too. And that black lives must begin to count.
It’s not just that black lives are important; All Lives Matter is important. It is understood that white lives matter too. That is the standard. Children’s books feature white characters. Standardized tests contain language geared towards white people, which is in line with the history of racism. Our marketing and advertising focus on white bodies. Products are designed with the white consumer in mind, and even the color “nude” for clothes like bras is modeled after white skin. Nearly every elected official that we’ve seen was white.
That’s why “All Lives Matter” is offensive and ineffective. It omits and minimizes the importance of the discrimination and violence that the black community is subject to daily.
If you have broken your hand, then your first step is to consult with a doctor regarding treating the hand that has been broken. Talking about it isn’t an act of disrespect to other healthier hand parts.
How “All Lives Matter” Is Perceived by People
Take a moment to think about this thought exercise. Imagine you attended an event that raised funds, awareness, and engaging in an exchange of thoughts about breast cancer. And suddenly, a crowd of people began to occupy the banquet hall and began shouting that all cancers matter. Discussion about breast cancer does not diminish the real worry about other types of cancer.
Imagine if when “Boston Strong” was trending following the Boston Marathon bombings in 2013, Many people began tweeting about “All Cities are Strong.”
Both are hypothetical and tactless instances that deliberately seek to influence these conversations, and that’s how “All Lives Matter” is perceived by people interested in or who appreciate and appreciate the Black Lives Matter movement.
There’s no reason to think that everyone’s lives aren’t hard or struggle or confront discrimination, but now, we’re trying to discuss black lives, a segment of people who aren’t even mentioned.
The Main Argument of ALM Supporters
One argument ALM supporters make against the movement is that they bring the topic of black-on-black crime to denounce the brutality of the police. However, black-on-black crime doesn’t exist. In the Bureau of Justice Statistics’ 2019 Report, 70 percent of criminals have the same ethnicity. As victims of crimes involving Black Americans and 62% for crimes involving white Americans.
In a recent news appearance with 11Alive Atlanta’s local news station, Clifton Crawley, the community chair of the Atlanta NAACP, states that the violence is multi-generational racism. Crawley declares that “There was always an intense anxiety about poverty, violence, and crime in our communities.” In addition, he points to the various organizations that are focused on this topic, including Street Groomers and My Brother’s Keeper.
Everyone Supports This Black Lives Matter Organization
Many have stated that they were against racism. And did not support the group by joining millions of people using the hashtag #blacklivesmatter or participating in demonstrations.
For instance, the defensive defender Tyrone Mings said following the criticisms of the England team’s decision to a knee. “It’s not about support for Black Lives Matter as an organization. It was a flimsy argument that was thrown at the group.“
A campaigner Femi Oluwole said BLM was an international movement. And “no one organization speaks for the entire Black Lives Matter movement.“
The Black Lives Matter organization often offered materials and advice to those protesting, Prof Deva Woodly said to The New York Times. However, the group didn’t organize every marches. Woodly said that new activists used the internet to connect with a large public.
Many supporters have pointed out that most marches were peaceful; however, the conservative US politicians and TV commentators claimed that Black Lives Matter was responsible for the death of cops. The BLM organization has said that this is not true: “We’re targeting the brutal system of police rather than individual police officers.“
The people who support Black Lives Matter vs. All Lives Matter have also claimed that those who claim “all life matters” and “white life matters” ignore the consequences of racial discrimination and slavery. They claim that the expression is a call for equality and a halt to racism since the lives of blacks are as significant as the lives of other people.
What Has Black Lives Matter Achieved?
In the US, measures have been made to stop police violence and alter how the law is applied. After the passing of Mr. Floyd, The phrase “defund the police” has been the talk of the town. Cities like Minneapolis, Portland, Philadelphia, and Seattle have begun shifting their money. Away from police departments and focusing on housing and education.
In the UK, protests attracted attention to the country’s colonial past. They also saw statues of people connected to the slave trade taken down.
Our Words Form Our Reality
“For several decades, we’ve observed that black unemployment is much higher than the whites. And we’ve known about the health disparities as well as the excessive use of force by police. But we’re not seeing all these facts in media simultaneously,” Hinkson says. “We are at a point where we are experiencing an entire storm of events that come together to reveal the reality of what is happening in the black community.“
The Bottom Line
Black people aren’t the people who are victims. We’ve remained in this country despite the Middle Passage, enslavement, and numerous other attempts to turn us into the footstool. That every person who isn’t Black or American Indian or Native American. (Survivors from a myriad of attempts to Indigenous elimination) enjoys the privilege of reaching up to the top of a ladder.
So that they are free to climb and fulfill what is known as the American dream, you are a part of the problem if you’re not speaking up. If you do not insist on change, you are providing approval. If you don’t insist on justice, know that you’re guilty and a supporter of injustice.