Climate Change Mitigation

Article Critique Instructions:

Read the following instruction to write a 500 word CRITIQUE of the article's study. Only a small portion of the total word count can be summary, rest must be critical analysis according to the below instructions. Make sure to point out and cite SPECIFICS:
I1) Summary; ii) Critique; and iii) Future Work.
I. Summary: Summarize the research article briefly. Describe the background on why the study was done, what were the important questions being asked, and what were the hypotheses or predictions? Briefly describe the methods and the results and how they related to the questions being asked. Please note that your summary should not paraphrase or quote material from the research article.
II. CRITIQUE: You should include approximately 3 SPECIFIC ISSUES in the critique. Please provide specifics. How did the issues affect results? Why? Did the authors address the criticism at all? What results does it invalidate? Does it affect the authors’ conclusions? What should be done differently to address the issue? How can it be avoided? Were the research methods used appropriate for the study? Did they use appropriate controls? Did they successfully answer their research questions? Positive points in the research article can also be addressed. Please include specifics.
III. Future Work: Include possible extensions of the research that could be completed.
What new questions have emerged? What directions would you like to see the research move in next? How might you do the research differently? Please include specifics.

Article Critique Sample Content Preview:

Article Critique on Climate Change Mitigation
Summary
Nath, Aziz, and Inoue (2014) conducted a much-needed study on homestead forests. Homestead forests have long been considered crucial, especially with regard to their ecological contribution, biodiversity conservation, economic contribution, and food security. However, in this study, Nath, Aziz, and Inoue (2014) focused on the contributions homestead forests have to biodiversity conservation through alleviation of climate change effects and the economic condition of households. The study seeks to answer the question of whether homestead forests play a more important role in the people living in Cox’s Bazar-Teknaf peninsula. The role the study investigates entails the alleviation of the impact of cyclones and the floristic diversity of the homestead forests in Cox’s Bazar-Teknaf peninsula. The method used for data collection entailed homestead and vegetation surveys that helped to reveal that the homestead forests do, in fact, have a crucial economic impact on the households. Further, it was revealed that the homestead forests help mitigate the impact of cyclones that would otherwise cause devastating environmental damage.
Critique
Fails to assess the distribution of species in the forests
The impact of literacy and experience on the diversity of species in the homestead forests is one omission that I found heavily impacted the study. In the study, the researchers make an effort to address the choice of species within the homestead forests. However, this is done from the point of knowledge regarding climate change and the problems emanating from climate change. However, there was the need to consider the literacy levels of the villagers and how this impacts their choice of species. Literacy levels would help showcase the underlying reason why certain species were preferred for particular households. This would also help to judge literacy levels against the pursuit of species that guarantee higher income levels. The authors do not appear to address this concern at all and, t...

Updated on January 26, 2024

Get the Whole Paper!

Not exactly what you need?

Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

Order

Climate Change Mitigation

You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to climate change: