3 pages/≈825 words
Literature & Language
Spirit catches you and you fall down (Term Paper Sample)
History and Cultures of Southeast Asia The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down Essay Questions Please type and single-space your responses to the following questions, clearly labeling the question being addressed and utilizing standard margins and a 12-point font. Your responses Include a citation (any standard format is fine) if you are: a) referring to information gleaned from outside of the Fadiman text or; b) using a direct quotation from any source. Responses getting high marks will demonstrate the following characteristics: a thorough treatment of the issues raised in the question, well written, tight organization, and thoughtful. 1. Discuss the central conflict of the book, i.e., the clash between the culture of the Hmong and the culture of ‘western biomedicine.' Why did the Lees act as they did regarding Lia Lee's condition? Why did her doctors act as they did? How did their (both the Lees' and the doctors') attitudes and actions reflect their underlying cultural beliefs regarding the body, wellness, illness, and healing? (~ 1/2 page) 2. Discuss at least three (3) aspects of Hmong culture that struck you as particularly interesting or unusual. Hmong culture has often been viewed by non-Hmong Americans as ‘backward'; the attitude is typically, ‘they (the Hmong) need to learn our (mainstream U.S) ways.' Taking the opposite approach, what lessons do you think the Hmong could teach mainstream U.S. society? (~1/2 page) 3. Towards the end of the book (pg. 259) Fadiman poses the question “Was the gulf [between the Lees and their doctors] unbridgeable?” What do you think? Reflect on the ‘eight questions' developed by Arthur Kleinman and his comments on page 261 in regards to this question. (~1/2 page) 4. What did you learn from this book? (i.e, discuss a few aspects or issues that particularly interested, surprised, or provoked you). (~1/2 page) source..
SPIRIT CATCHES YOU AND YOU FALL DOWN Name: Institution: Date: 1. Discuss the central conflict of the book, i.e., the clash between the culture of the Hmong and the culture of â€˜western biomedicine.' Why did the Lees act as they did regarding Lia Lee's condition? Why did her doctors act as they did? How did their (both the Lees' and the doctors') attitudes and actions reflect their underlying cultural beliefs regarding the body, wellness, illness, and healing? The cultural beliefs of the Hmong people differ with the way the doctors in California perceive the disease that Lee suffers. The people of Hmong belief that the health status is linked to the spirit. When Lee is in a comma, the physicians conclude that it is an "electromagnetic storm inside her headâ€, but the family of the child believes that some of the twelve souls she possesses left her body (Harding, 2013). At the age of three, Lia Lee suffers seizure which the family attributes it to the slamming of the front door. The belief was seen as substandard to the physicians because they did not comprehend the traditional remedies the family used. When Lia Lee was three years old, the doctors moved the child to a foster-care for special treatment. The action caused conflict with the parents of the Lia Lee. The parents of Lee saw the relocation as an excuse of the doctors to have a vacation. Some form of American medical practices clashes with the Hmong belief of reincarnation (Harding, 2013). Hmong do not allow surgical treatment which involves cutting because it is a gateway of an evil spirit into the body. On the other hand, western culture does not believe in spirits, but their treatment is based on scientific knowledge. The relationship between the physician and lee's family is dismal due to a misunderstanding on the cause of the ailment. According to the people of Hmong, people should not undergo surgery. Surgery involves opening wounds and body tissues. Evil spirits can enter the human body through the open places. They believe that the soul can exist inside or outside the human body (Chiu, 2010). When Lia Lee is in a comma, they link the condition to a soul being taken away from her body. Another interesting thing about the belief of Hmong people is that when Lia Lee suffers the first seizure, the parents attributes it the noise caused by the slamming of a door by Yer- Lia's older sister. The noise frightens one of the Lee's souls and leaves her (Harding, 2013). It is paradoxical that while the family was concerned with the health status of their child, they also believed that seizures were one way of bein...
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:
- US Government and Minimum Wage Term PaperDescription: US Government and Minimum Wage Term Paper...3 pages/≈825 words | 3 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Term Paper |
- Race descrimination and its effectsDescription: Racial discrimination occurs when anyone is denied something, forced to do something they do not want or treated unfavorably because of their skin color...5 pages/≈1375 words | 3 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Term Paper |
- The differences in the economies of the North and the South were one of the major causes of . . .Description: Undergraduate writing level 10 pages Literature and Language Format Style English (U.S.) Term Paper. The differences in the economies of the North and the South were one of the major causes of the Civil War."...10 pages/≈2750 words | 10 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Term Paper |