The Opinion of Justice Keen on the Speluncean Explorers (Essay Sample)
You have chosen one of the decisions concerning the Speluncean Explorers. (Opinion of Justice Keen)
The paper will consist of three paragraphs. The first paragraph will summarize the court's opinion. You will not summarize the facts of the case, just the judge's decision. The last sentence of the first paragraph will state whether you agree or disagree.
The second paragraph will explain the first reason you agree or disagree. The third paragraph will explain the second reason you agree or disagree. You will not summarize your reasons.
I UPLOADED TWO CASES OF SPELUNCEAN EXPLORERS FOR JUST IN CASE. I DO NOT KNOW IF THAT TWO CASES WILL HELP YOU WRITING THE ESSAY. AND I HAVE NO IDEA IF THE TWO CASES RELATED TO KEEN'S OPPINION OR NOT. I JUST UPLOADed EVERYTHING WHAT MY PROFESSOR GAVE TO ME. THANK YOU.
The Opinion of Justice Keen on the Speluncean Explorers
In the case of the Speluncean Explorers, four cavers are convicted for the killing of Roger Whetmore, one of their own. According to the law in Newgarth, any intentional murder is punishable by death. The Chief Executive received a petition to reduce the conviction from the death penalty to a six month’s prison sentence (Fuller, 1949). In this regard, Justice Keen, a member of Newgarth’s Supreme Court gave his opinion regarding the case. Justice Keen argues that executive leniency and the morality of the actions of the accused are not relevant to the case (Fuller, 1949). According to Justice Keen, the question that the court needs to deliberate upon should be based on the application of the law of Newgarth and the determination of whether the accused cavers knowingly murdered Whetmore. He asserts that there should be a distinction between the legal and moral facets of the case. Justice Keen’s decision implies that the judiciary should not make an appeal to the Executive for leniency on the case. Such appeals should only be made by private citizens but not by an arm of the government. Again, he points out that the morality
You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to death penalty:
- Chapter 8: Read The Provided Article And Answer The QuestionsDescription: The old master’s youngest son died and followed by Andrew’s death which left Lucretia to share the estate he left behind. His death happened while he was visiting 3 daughters in Hillsborough...1 page/≈275 words | 2 Sources | MLA | Literature & Language | Book Report |
- Gabriel Marie Marquez In The Book Chronicle Of A Death ForetoldDescription: Compare the ways in which the write Gabriel Marie Marquez in the book “Chronicle of a death foretold” has used the abundance or lack of money to either drive the plot of the development of characters....1 page/≈550 words | 1 Source | MLA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- Willy Loman: The Death Of A Salesman Review Assignment Paper 2Description: Describe the type of sales Willy Loman was involved in. Was it more of a transnational based sale or a customer centered approach?...2 pages/≈550 words | No Sources | APA | Business & Marketing | Essay |