Philosophy: Ethics & Society Religion & Theology Essay (Essay Sample)
The lengths for each answer will d But the total number of words should not exceed 1300 (including footnotes).
Footnotes should be used for citations only.
All you need to answer these questions are the texts and your note I discourage you from using any outside sources. But if you do, make sure to cite them.
Though you are free to discuss answers to these questions with your classmates, the written material must be your own and stated in your own words. Any suspected plagiarism will be submitted to the Academic Integrity Office.
Number and letter your answers.
Failure to follow all of these directions will result in a penalty.
How to Cite:
When citing an author, just quote the text, footnote it, and reference the author and the title of the piece you’re quoting from. For example:
1 Buchanan, Allen “Theories of Secession”, p.35
If the next citation uses the same source and but a different page, just write ‘ibid.’ followed by the new page number. So, for example, suppose in footnote 2, you again want to cite something Buchanan said in “Theories of Secession” – but this time, from p. 40. Because in footnote 1 you already cited the author and paper, you can just write:
2 ibid., p.40
If after this you cite a different author, do so in full (as in the example of footnote 1). If after that you once again cite Buchanan, you do so in full.
Answer both questions.
Alan Buchanan worries that enshrining Primary Rights Theories in law would result in bad consequences.
A) Explain Buchanan’s worry. David Copp argues that the question of whether we have a moral right to secession is "morally prior" to the question of whether international law ought to recognize such a right.
B) Describe this response to the Buchanan’s worry.
C) Do you find this response convincing? Why or why not?
Critics of Primary Rights Theories of secession argue that powerful political subunits might use a threat to secede to extract concessions from the parent-state. It seems, then, that modeling international law on a Primary Rights Theory of secession would allow powerful political subunits to engage in coercion.
A) Explain Christopher Wellman's response to this criticism. In doing so, be sure to describe what in general counts as a wrongfully coercive threat on Wellman’s view.
B) Do you agree with Wellman’s response to the argument that Primary Rights Theory give subunits too much coercive power? Why or why not?
Philosophy: Ethics and Society
Question 1: Enshrining Primary Rights Theories in Law
Alan Buchanan has considerable concerns that enshrining primary rights theories in law would result in adverse consequences. Primary Right Theories are the predispositions whose assertion is that "certain groups can have a (general) right to secede in the absence of any injustice."Such people's demands extend beyond the injustice part to include the nationalist principle and ascriptive characteristics as secession bases. Buchanan argues that such theories are very poor in facilitating reforms considering that they create perverse incentives. Primary Right Theories have abstract concepts as to why they should form a new state or nation and thus, in a major position to encourage behavior that undermines morality or, in this case, moral and sound principles of internal law. Also, they can be an obstacle to pursuing morally progressive strategies for conflict resolution. Finally, individual liberty or the government's greater efficiency are elements at stake.[Buchanan, Allen “Theories of Secession”, p.35]
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
- Abortion Essays
- Legalize marijuana Essays
- Learning styles Essays
- Same sex marriage Essays
- Animal right Essays
- Slavery Essays
- Teenage pregnancy Essays
- American dream Essays
- Immigration Essays
- Racism Essays
- Global warming Essays
- Religion Essays
- Gay marriage Essays
- Police brutality Essays
- Love Essays
- Animal testing Essays
- Religion & Theology Essay: Judaism, Christianity, and IslamDescription: Different religions have existed from historical times, as different splinter groups continue to emerge in the present time. People identify with doctrines they believe associate with their social-cultural system, which dictates their worldviews, morals, ethics, and behaviors....1 page/≈275 words | MLA | Religion & Theology | Essay |
- Townes, Emilie and Gender Equality and Justice in Contemporary TheologyDescription: The essay will make a claim an argument about a Christian doctrine within the scope of the class based on a single primary text chosen from the work of one of the theologians provided below. ...6 pages/≈1650 words | MLA | Religion & Theology | Essay |
- Hinduism Caste System Religion & Theology Essay PaperDescription: It is believed that the groups originated from the Hindu God of creation popularly Known as Brahma. Brahmins, who occupy the top level of the caste are believed to have been created from Brahma's head, and they are mainly intellectuals. Kshatriyas occupy the second topmost level in the caste...4 pages/≈1100 words | MLA | Religion & Theology | Essay |