Monthly Journal: The Johnson-Reed Act And Boundary Creation (Essay Sample)
1. What are the main arguments of the authors?
2. What conclusions can you draw by putting the authors in conversation with each other?
3. What questions haven't the authors answered yet?
4. What are some critiques of their arguments can you offer?
5. Do you agree or disagree with the authors? (Yes I'm in agreement)
Your University of Affiliation
Your Subject and Section
November 3, 2017
In the book titled Impossible subjects: Illegal aliens and the making of modern America, the author Mae Ngai first discussed existing immigration practices in America even before the inception of The Johnson-Reed Act of 1924. After providing an overview, Ngai started Chapter one, entitled The Johnson-Reed act of 1924 and the Reconstruction of Race in Immigration Law, and discussed it using a historical analytical approach. According to her, before the law was passed, immigration to America was highly supported by the government itself because it serves as a catalyst for economic growth through additional capital and increase in manpower (17). Nonetheless, as immigration continued to grow and place certain risks for the government, the Johnson-Reed Immigration Act of 1924 was vetoed by the government in order to reduce the number of immigrants, which are continuously increasing in numbers (Ngai, 17). However, despite the seeming “good intentions” of the state in doing so, what they didn't realize is that this act of placing “quotas” that is rooted from national origins would lead to “making of racial boundaries of citizenship” (Ngai, 17). In line with this article written by Ngai, this article would provide an analysis of her work and the arguments included there. In the succeeding chapter, the gaps of knowledge would also be addressed by asking the relevant questions that are left unanswered as well as providing a response to Ngai's arguments. Nonetheless, in relation to our previous discussions about Marxism, I believe that Ngai's analysis of The Johnson-Reed Act is accurate in the sense that it creates a “relations of production”, which then created a persisting type of “social consciousness” (Marx, 91), which then created this “racial boundaries of citizenship” (Ngai, 17).
The Johnson-Reed Act and Boundary Creation
In her article, Ngai argued that a nation's concept of “sovereignty” is one of the strongest factors that influence the creation of policies regarding immigration policies. As exemplified today, countries limit the number of immigrants that could go into their territory based on a risks assessment of social, economic, political, and even environmental reasons, among others. According to Ngai, the reason for this is that in international relationships between countries, immigration is almost always viewed as risks towards the encroach
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
- Fear Essays
- Freedom of speech Essays
- Women rights Essays
- Modest proposal Essays
- Domestic violence Essays
- The story of an hour Essays
- Hamlet Essays
- Social networking Essays
- A good man is hard to find Essays
- Illegal immigration Essays
- Civil rights movement Essays
- Poetry analysis Essays
- Racial discrimination Essays
- Sociological imagination Essays
- Feminist Essays
- Industrial revolution Essays
You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to immigration:
- Describe Immigration Laws And Potential Illegal ImmigrantsDescription: You explore your position on the topic of immigration laws. Select an immigration law for this Discussion and consider whether or not that law is justifiable....2 pages/≈550 words | 3 Sources | APA | Management | Essay |
- Types Of Illegal Immigrants: Effects Of Immigration On Crime RateDescription: According to the UNDOC 57% of migrants have entered the use by using traffickers to smuggle them into the country. This paper discusses the relationship between illegal immigrants and crime rate....3 pages/≈825 words | 2 Sources | APA | Literature & Language | Essay |
- NATO, Canadian-American Relations since World War 2Description: The relationship between the United States can be attributed because both nations share historical ties that have existed over a long period...2 pages/≈550 words | 6 Sources | MLA | History | Essay |