Sign In
Not register? Register Now!
Essay Available:
Pages:
4 pages/≈1100 words
Sources:
Check Instructions
Level:
APA
Subject:
Health, Medicine, Nursing
Type:
Essay
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 17.28
Topic:

Critical Evaluation of Belbin Profile Health, Medicine, Nursing Essay (Essay Sample)

Instructions:

See the example paper-
You will need to critically evaluate your profile based on your input and the input of 4 observers of your choice. (see the attached report from myself and 4 observers from my team) - I am a medical officer, while 4 observers are my team manager, and 2 doctors and 1 nurse.
By critically evaluate we mean see if the profile contributes to reality. Consider why your observers scored you in a certain way and reflect on your strengths and weaknesses (when did your skills work with you or against you when working in a team – you can give brief examples - explames from working in medical team).
You may wish to consider reflecting on 2 strong roles and 2 weak roles for example and consider how they contributed (or not) to team working whilst linking it with current literature. You can also think of how your leadership attributes apply to public health leadership. **Refer to the belbin report too!
For this assignment you have to complete:
1. Personal Belbin Profile (done and attached) - you can see from the example- copy and quote some useful data from the belbin report for your reflection
2. A critical evaluation of your personal profile in relation to your contribution to team working and application of these skills to public health leadership
The word limit is 1000 words exclusive of the reference list and appendices. - make sure references are needed. and refer to the report for all the reflection. the case / the examples use for reflection can be make it up by yourself but must be based on working environment in hospital with teams.

 

MARKING CRITERIA FOR CRITICAL REFLECTION ON BELBIN PROFILE

Module Code:           7WLM 0020   Candidate:                                                     Marker:                                                             Date: 

 

 

 

Grade

Reflective Evaluation of the attributes of the Personal Belbin Profile

Critical Application of Belbin profile to job demands

Personal Contribution to team working in practice

Consideration of Skills needed for Public Health Leadership

 

 

Weighting 5%

Weighting 10% 

Weighting 5%

Weighting 5%

COMPETENT

80-100

 

Outstanding

Outstanding definition and understanding of personal attributes as defined in the Belbin profile Outstanding range of reference source s applied.

Outstanding critical evaluation demonstrating outstanding understanding of context and team issues.

Outstanding breadth and depth of references.

Outstanding integration of literature into work.

Outstanding critical understanding of personal contribution to team working.

Outstanding breadth and depth of references.

Outstanding integration of literature into work.

Outstanding consideration of public health leadership skills demonstrated.

Outstanding breadth &depth of literature utilised.

Outstanding integration of literature into work.

 

70-79

 

Excellent

Excellent definition and understanding of personal attributes as defined in the Belbin profile. Excellent range of reference sources.

Excellent critical evaluation demonstrating excellent understanding of context and team issues.

Excellent breadth and depth of references.

Excellent integration of literature into work.

Excellent critical understanding of personal contribution to team working.

Excellent breadth & depth of literature utilised.

Excellent integration of literature into work.

Excellent consideration of public health leadership skills demonstrated

Excellent breadth & depth of literature utilised.

Excellent integration of literature into work.

60-69

 

Very Good

Very good definition and understanding of personal attributes as defined in the Belbin profile.

Very good range of reference sources.

Very good critical evaluation demonstrating very good understanding of context and team issues.

Very good breadth and depth of references.

Very good integration of literature into work.

Very good critical understanding of personal contribution to team working.

Very good breadth & depth of literature utilised.

Literature integrated into work very well.

 

Very good consideration of public health leadership skills demonstrated.

Very good breadth & depth of literature utilised.

Literature integrated into work very well.

 

50-59

 

Good/Satisfactory

Minimum expected competency

Good to satisfactory definition and understanding personal attributes as defined in the Belbin profile. Good to satisfactory range of reference sources.

Good to satisfactory critical evaluation demonstrating good to satisfactory understanding of context and team issues.

Good to satisfactory breadth and depth of references.

Good to satisfactory integration of literature into work.

Good to satisfactory critical understanding of personal contribution to team working.

Depth appropriate to topic but moderate breadth or vice versa.

Good to satisfactory integration of literature into the work.

 

Good to satisfactory consideration of public health leadership skills demonstrated

Depth appropriate to topic but moderate breadth or vice versa.

Good to satisfactory integration of literature into the work.

 

LACKS COMPETENCE

40-49

 

Marginal Fail

Poorly worded definition and limited understanding of personal attributes as defined in the Belbin profile

Poor range of reference sources.

Limited degree of critical evaluation demonstrating

 

limited understanding of context and team issues.

Limited breadth and depth of references.

Limited degree of integration of literature into work.

Limited critical understanding of personal contribution to team working.

Limited degree of integration of literature into work.

Limited consideration of public health leadership skills demonstrated  

Limited breadth and depth of literature utilised.

Limited degree of integration of literature into work.

20-39

 

Clear Fail

 

Very poorly worded definition and very limited understanding of personal attributes as defined in the Belbin profile.

Very poor range of reference sources.

 

Lacking detail in critical evaluation demonstrating an inadequate understanding of the context and team issues.

Inadequate breadth and depth of references.

Inadequate degree of integration of literature into work.

Poor critical understanding of personal contribution to team working.

Lacks breadth & depth of literature.

Some literature irrelevant to topic area.

 

Poor consideration of public health leadership skills demonstrated Lacks breadth & depth of literature.

Some literature irrelevant to topic area.

 

1-19

Nothing of merit

Little or nothing of merit.

Incomplete definition.

No understanding and confusion personal attributes as defined in the Belbin profile.

No references

Little or nothing of merit.

No critical demonstration and no understanding of the context and team issues

Only descriptive account provided.

No references.

Little or nothing of merit.

No understanding of personal contribution to team working. demonstrated.

No references.

 

Little or nothing of merit.

No consideration of public health leadership skills demonstrated.

No references.

 

 

Section Marks

 

 

 

 

Total Mark:

 

 

             


Comments (focussing on areas for improvement):

 

 

 

 

source..
Content:


Critical Evaluation of the Belbin Profile
Your Name
Subject and Section
Professor’s Name
Date of Submission
Introduction
Team members in a group are often guided by the personality stereotypes. Individuality helps in accomplishing the work by honing one’s aptitude and skills. However, this also posed a risk of promoting fragmented responsibilities and fragmented communication (Belbin, 2012).
To have a better understanding of individual roles, we are required to complete the Belbin Team Report. I asked a total of four observers: my team manager, two other doctors, and a nurse. The report reflects the perspectives of individual group members.
Reflection and Critical Application of Belbin
6515102881630Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 1. Self-Perception Plus Four Observer AssessmentsFigure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 1. Self-Perception Plus Four Observer Assessments651979944200
Observers’ Perspective
The graph shows how the team members and I perceive my leadership in the group. Currently, I work as a medical officer in a local government setting.

...
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

Other Topics:

  • Intervention Programs Report Health, Medicine, Nursing Essay
    Description: The abuse of opioid is a disease with natural history (Stoicea, N., et al 2019). The United States was drastically affected and it arose as a result of medical practitioners’ efforts to manage pain. Pharmaceutical manufacturers commonly referred to as “The Big Pharma”...
    2 pages/≈550 words | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Essay |
  • Nurse case scenerio Health, Medicine, Nursing Essay
    Description: A patient with hypokalemia has ordinarily low potassium levels; this means that the readings in hypokalemia are below normokalemia of 3.5–5.5 mmol/L and values that are below 2.5 mmol/L are considered life threatening (Formiga et al., 2019, (Mani, 2018). It must be noted...
    3 pages/≈825 words | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Essay |
  • Dental Hygiene Health, Medicine, Nursing Essay Paper
    Description: I have always had an interest in dentistry since it is a profession that involves helping other people. I am very interested in studying human biology to create an impact on society by helping people. Considering that I have compassion in science, then a career in science would be an excellent...
    1 page/≈275 words | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Essay |
HIRE A WRITER FROM $11.95 / PAGE
ORDER WITH 15% DISCOUNT!