Critical Evaluation of the Articles or Source (Essay Sample)
Module 3 - SLP
Business Ethics and Virtue Ethics
In the Module 3 SLP, we turn to information literacy: You will be exploring the resources and use of the TUI Library. Next, you will be learning how to evaluate the quality of your sources.
First, please review the following list of websites. Sites such as those below (e.g., cheat sites, pay term paper sites) are prohibited from use in graduate-level papers. Please note that this is not an all-inclusive list. Also, please note that Wikipedia.org is included on this list.
www.wikipedia.org -- Specifically, Wikipedia should be avoided as graduate-level resource - Wikipedia is not peer-reviewed. Indeed, Wiki admits that its articles are not credible - see the following: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/About_Wikipedia#Reliability
Please review the following articles relating to evaluation of sources:
Cornell University. How to critically analyze information sources. Retrieved March 31, 2011, from http://olinuris.library.cornell.edu/ref/research/skill26.htm
University of California Berkeley. Critical evaluation of resources. Retrieved March 31, 2011, from http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/instruct/guides/evaluation.html
Write a 2-3 page paper, in which you do the following:
Evaluate several journal articles and websites, and determine whether each source is scholarly or non-scholarly.
Keys to the Assignment
- Locate the following articles in the TUI Library using ProQuest (or EBSCO if you cannot find in ProQuest).
- Using the Cornell University website as a guide, perform a critical evaluation of each article or source, explaining why each of the articles or sources below is a scholarly or non-scholarly resource.
- For each source below, give as many reasons as you can as to why the source is scholarly or non-scholarly.
- In your Reference section, properly cite each source using APA style.
- Edmund F. Byrne - author of the May, 2002 article entitled "Business ethics: A helpful hybrid in search of integrity." Published in in the Journal of Business Ethics, Volume #37, Issue #2. Article is found on pages 121-133.
- Published in September 24, 2011 issue of The Economist. Article entitled "Business: The view from the top, and bottom; Corporate culture." Pages 76-77.
- Article authored by Jonathan Dee entitled a “A Toy Maker’s Conscience," and published in the New York Times Magazine. New York: Dec 23, 2007. p. 34 (6 pages).
- Article entitled: “75 years of lessons learned: chief executive officer values and corporate social responsibility,” authored by Carol-Ann Tetrault Sirsly, and published in the Journal of Management History in 2009. Volume 15, and Issue 1. p. 78
- Article entitled “Corporation communication, ethics, and operational identity: a case study of Benetton.” Was authored by Janet L. Borgerson, Jonathan E. Schroeder, Martin Escudero Magnusson, and Frank Magnusson. Found in a journal entitled "Business Ethics." Oxford: July, 2009. Volume #18, Issue #3; p. 209.
Your paper will be evaluated on the following:
- Precision - Does the paper address the question(s) or task(s)?
- Breadth - Is the full breadth of the subject (i.e., the Keys to the Assignment) addressed?
- Depth - Does the paper address the topic in sufficient depth and include the background reading and other background resources as references?
- Critical thinking - Is the subject thought about critically (i.e., accurately, logically, relevantly, and precisely)?
- Clarity - Is the writing clear and are the concepts articulated properly? Are paraphrasing and synthesis of concepts the primary means of responding to the questions or are points conveyed through excessive use of quotations?
- Organization - Is the paper well written? Are the grammar, spelling, and vocabulary appropriate for graduate-level work? Are headings included in all papers longer than two pages?
- Referencing (citations and references) - Does the paper include citations and quotation marks where appropriate? Are the references from the background reading and assignment present and properly cited? Are all the references listed in the bibliography present and referred to via citation?
- Application - Are the concepts of the module appropriately applied to the subject?
Tips and Suggestions
- Your paper will be evaluated based on the rigor of your assessment of each of the above seven sources. Be sure that you give as many reasons as you can as to why each source is a scholarly source or a non-scholarly source. Do not give bullet points, but write formally (in full sentences).
- Be sure that you properly cite all of the above sources as end references (see the Purdue OWL site for proper APA referencing of websites).
- Be sure to follow the guidelines in the Well-Written Paper
CRITICAL EVALUATION OF THE ARTICLES OR SOURCE
Business and Marketing
Date of Submission:
Critical Evaluation of the articles or source
â€œEdmund F. Byrne - author of the May, 2002 article entitled "Business ethics: A helpful hybrid in search of integrity." Published in in the Journal of Business Ethics, Volume #37, Issue #2. Article is found on pages 121-133.â€ Using Cornell University website as a guide, systematic analysis on this article shows that it is a scholarly article. Reasons being that the author is an associate professor at Indiana University-Purdue University, Department of Philosophy. He has published over 25 scholarly articles, which have been cited by other writers in their articles. The article is still relevant for the researchers in the field of business to consult considering the publication date. Additionally, the article is published in scholarly and popular journal of business ethics. Lastly, the author followed the scholarly writing style where the content of the articles are logically organized and clearly presented (Byre, 2002).
â€œPublished in September 24, 2011 issue of The Economist. Article entitled "Business: The view from the top, and bottom; corporate culture." Pages 76 -77.â€ The evaluation of this article showed that it is non-scholarly article since the author is not indicated. It is impossible to determine educational background, insti...
- Job Market: Employment Trends Research Assignment PaperDescription: Why is it important to be aware of trends in the job market? How can the information on these websites help you with career planning?...1 page/≈275 words | 3 Sources | APA | Business & Marketing | Essay |
- Team workDescription: Team work Business and Marketing Essay Undergraduate level...11 pages/≈3025 words | 15 Sources | APA | Business & Marketing | Essay |
- Week 1 Assignment Paper: Describe Crisis LeadershipDescription: Describe Crisis Leadership as discussed in the article. In your own words, what are the major factors in crisis leadership? Models of training...1 page/≈275 words | 3 Sources | APA | Business & Marketing | Essay |