Theory of Informed Consent and Pharmaceutical Company Dealings by Sussman and Goldsmith

Reflection
Jordan Goldsmith
Goldsmith presents a clear and concise point regarding the theory of informed consent. First, there is the presentation of the physicians’ perspective, who are believed to see informed consent as simply a hurdle to their delivery of tasks. With their knowledge and education, physicians are indeed highly likely to feel that they know what is best for their patients in all instances. This point was brought out with the greatest affirmation, with Goldsmith noting that some physicians could even perceive informed consent as outside interference. On the other hand, patients are at some disadvantage, as revealed by Goldsmith, especially considering their limitations in knowledge. Therefore, as rightfully pointed out by Goldsmith, many tend to agree with their physicians. However, since physicians are the ones who understand patients better, Goldsmith points out that they ought to try and bridge the gap between themselves and their patients. I feel like Goldsmith does present a well-balanced account of informed consent with either side aptly captured.
Erin Sussman
Sussman’s response to the question is structured and aptly answers every section. First, Sussman indicates their belief in a gap between the theory of informed consent. Here, the physicians are said to be in a position of power and therefore ought to provide their patients with as much information as is needed for them to be able to make informed decisions. Aside from providing information to aid in the decision-making process, Sussman believes that patients should be given the space to ask questions and, as they say, ‘sleep on it.’ The belief here is that patients will have more time to think and ask better questions. The insurance company’s role is also included in this discussion, with the scope of coverage seen as a major factor in patients’ decision-making processes. Lastly, Sussman points out that patients’ decision aids should be considere...