Article Review Assignment Paper: Overview of the Study (Article Critique Sample)
Describe the relevance and purpose of the study in 1-2 paragraphs. In this and other sections, avoid the use of quotes.
Use the Scientific Merit Rating Scale of the National Standards Report. Separate criteria are identified for group and single subject research design. Describe the extent to which the research design can lead to credible results in your conclusions section.
Use the Scientific Merit Rating Scale of the National Standards Report. Separate criteria are identified for tests/scales/checklists and direct behavioral observation. Describe the extent to which the quality of the dependent variable impacts the credibility of the study in the conclusion section.
Describe the extent to which treatment fidelity data are reported and the quality of these data based on the Scientific Merit Rating Scale of the National Standards Project. Include the extent to which this impacts the credibility of the study in your conclusion section.
Overview of the study
The study is well developed relative to the fact that it is developed one of the topics that is not well evaluated in research. While the idea about replacing bad behavior in children with socially acceptable behavior is mentioned in a number of resources, there is not much in terms of research that has been developed to indicate its success as a tool (Carr & Durand, 1985). This study brings the significance of the approach as tool to behavior change.
Quality of research design
The research uses two experiments to evaluate the subject matter on the behavioral changes and how best to induce socially acceptable changes in the children. The first experiment successfully addresses the issue of behavior (Scientific Merit Rating Scale, 2014). In the second experiment, the research addresses the issue of replacing the behavioral challenges with socially acceptable behaviors. The experiments are sequential and thus making the entire research quite credible and proves the hypothesis, feeding into the current knowledge base on the topic.
Quality of dependent measure
A review of the dependent variable indicates that the research is quite satisfactory. This is relative to the fact that the research addresses the element of behavior change. In this case, the research paper addresses the issue of behavior change with reference to adopting socially acceptable changes (Scientific Merit Rating Scale, 2014).
Evidence of treatment fidelity
A review of the paper also shows that the treatments have some high level of fidelity ("Module 7: Fidelity Assessment", 2016). This with reference to the organizational element of the content and the establishment of the main ideas in the paper in context of behavioral changes (Scientific Merit...
- Teachers' Views On Conducting Formative Assessment Within Contemporary ClassroomsDescription: The main idea from the article that is applied to personal assessment experiences and/or student teaching observations and future teaching plans...2 pages/≈550 words | 1 Source | APA | Psychology | Article Critique |
- The Effects of Parental Support and Self-EsteemDescription: Individual and social predictors of internalizing symptoms in college and university students; also the effects of parental support through self-esteem....1 page/≈275 words | 1 Source | APA | Psychology | Article Critique |
- Rubric For Group Journal Club Reports: Perceptual CharacteristicsDescription: The focus has been turned to investigating the “perceptual characteristics” of steam/bounce displays. In recent times, studies have been directed at attempting to identify moving objects....1 page/≈550 words | 1 Source | APA | Psychology | Article Critique |