Managing Osteoarthritis: Article Critique, The Aim of Study (Article Critique Sample)
Article Analysis #1
Read the article “Managing Osteoarthritis: Comparisons of Chair Yoga, Reiki, and Education (Pilot Study).” Provide a hard copy to the instructor along with the analysis. The analysis should range from 3 to 5 pages excluding a cover page and reference page. It will count for 10% of the total grade.Provide the name of the journal, publication year, volume number, and key words. (1 paragraph)
What is the aim of this study? (1 paragraph)
Provide a summary of a theory or conceptual model and describe it. (1 paragraph)
Summarize the literature regarding what previous research studies reported about Yoga and Reiki. (1/2 page)
Describe the type of research:
a. Is this study basic research or applied research? Provide the rationale and evidence for your response.
b. Is this qualitative, quantitative, or mixed method research? Provide the rationale for your response.
c. Is this cross-sectional or longitudinal research? Provide the rationale for your response.
d. Is this descriptive, exploratory, predictive, explanatory, or evaluation research? Provide the rationale for your response.
List the research questions. (1 paragraph)
What type of research design did the researchers use? Provide a rationale for the design. (1 paragraph)
Identify the intervention(s) used in the study. (1 paragraph)
Describe the sample recruitment process, including inclusion and exclusion criteria. (1 paragraph)
10. Describe the sampling method (how were the participants recruited?).
11. Report the main outcomes of the study related to each research question. (1 paragraph)
12. What instruments (standardized measures) were used to measure the outcomes? Describe each instrument, including reliability and/or validity scores. (1/2 page)
13. Briefly summarize the study findings. (1/2 page)
14. What are the implications for future research and policy and for social work practice? (1/2 page)?source..
The name of the journal from which the article is derived is Holistic Nursing Practice. The journal was published in 2011 and its volume number is 25. The key words from the abstract of the article include: osteoarthritis, Reiki, yoga, and Holist Nurs Pract 2011;25(6):316-326.
The aim of this study was to determine whether chair yoga and Reiki techniques affect pain, physical functions, and depressive states in comparison with an exclusively educational and discussion program in older adults suffering from osteoarthritis (OA).
The study is based on a theoretical framework known as the gate control theory of pain. The gate control theory of pain is based on the understanding that chronic pain has both mental as well as physical elements.
Pilkington, Kirkwood, Rampes, and Richardson (2005) define yoga as a harmony creation therapy. The researchers posit that the therapy brings about a state of harmony between the mind and body in order to maintain health and a state of well-being in an individual. Normally, yoga consists of five major principles: (a) adequate relaxation, (b) adequate exercise, (c) adequate breathing, (d) adequate diet, and (e) meditation. Interventions using yoga therapies have been extensively studied in several populations, and have been found to play a significant role in reducing stress and depression. For example, a certain study seeking to evaluate the importance of a 24-week yoga program on pain, medication usage, physical function, and mental state in a group of osteoarthritis patients found a significant reduction in the level of lower back pain in the chair yoga group. Additionally, the OA patients achieved improved physical functions and reduced depressive states. The control group did not achieve any reduction in pain, depression, or use of pain medication.
On the other hand, Reiki therapy is considered a healing therapy that utilizes some form of energy from the hands of a Reiki practitioner; the practitioner channels bodily energies to the recipient. It is thought that by directing the bodily energies into the recipient, some form of harmony and balance is provided; the harmony and balance yielded helps in improving the spiritual, mental, physical, and emotional well-being of a person. The effects of a form of Reiki studied in a group of 300 participants showed significant improvements in physical and psychological functions.
This particular research is categorized as applied research. Applied research is normally conducted to study a specific situation or phenomenon and come up with new ideas and solutions. This particular research was carried out to determine the effects of chair yoga, Reiki and education programs on management of osteoarthritis pain, emotional health, physical functioning, and well-being. The study is also confirmatory because it seeks to confirm whether already known treatment regimens are indeed significant in alleviating several challenges in osteoarthritis.
The study is also a mixed m...
- Analysis and Application of Clinical Practice Guidelines Description: You will develop a summary that you could use within an evidence-based practice (EBP) committee or related venue to share with your colleagues. ...4 pages/≈1100 words | 1 Source | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |
- Integrating the primary health careDescription: Health and Medicine: Integrating the primary health care Article Critique...1 page/≈275 words | 1 Source | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |
- Central Line Associated Bloodstream Infections ResearchDescription: Describe the general advantages and disadvantages of the two research approaches featured in the articles. Use examples from the articles for support....3 pages/≈825 words | 5 Sources | APA | Health, Medicine, Nursing | Article Critique |