Sign In
Not register? Register Now!
Pages:
2 pages/≈550 words
Sources:
1 Source
Style:
APA
Subject:
Education
Type:
Article Critique
Language:
English (U.S.)
Document:
MS Word
Date:
Total cost:
$ 7.92
Topic:

The Use of First Language in the Second-Language Classroom

Article Critique Instructions:

Complete a critical review of  the second article you have identified as relevant to your study (around 2 pages, double-spaced APA format). 

The review should include: 

A very brief summary of the article which relates it to the research approaches we’ve been discussing  (No more than one half page). An evaluation of the article- 1.5-2 pages.

Among the issues to be addressed are:           

Introduction and Literature Review: What is the background of the related research? How does this research relates to the field as a whole? What is the origin of conceptual framework? Describe the theoretical foundation 

Participants: How participants were selected? What are criteria for selection ? Describe the participants with detail appropriate to the study and its goal.

Methodology: What is the methodology? What are research questions and/or hypotheses? Provide operational definitions for ambiguous terms, variables or constructs. Are the sources of any questionnaires or protocols available? Is the methodology a good match for the research questions and/or hypotheses? Why or why not? Are the limitations of the study delineated? 

Results and Conclusions: Synthesize the results of the study. Are there helpful charts, figures, and tables? 

Additional Issues: Do you think this study could be replicable based on the information in the article? How might you improve the design or analysis?What (if anything) is still not clear to you? What additional aspects of the study would you like to address 

Then complete the critical review table.

Article Critique Sample Content Preview:

Critical Article Review
Student's Name
Institutional Affiliation
Course Code and Title
Professor's Name
Due Date
Critical Article Review
Mara Salmona Madriñan's 2014 article "The Use of First Language in the Second-Language Classroom: A Support for Second Language Acquisition" outlines the significance of using the first language to teach learners in second-language classrooms. The article aims to identify the benefits of using the mother tongue when teaching, such as enhancing acquiring a second language. The article's findings reflected that students benefit when teachers use their first language since it transfers concepts from the first to the new second language. Undoubtedly, bilingualism teaching enhances understanding and the proficiency level of the second language.
The author used related literature with educational backgrounds. He used literature from research studies conducted in different bilingual schools. The research relates to education since students in varying schools quickly learn a new language when teachers use their first language (Madriñan, 2014). The origin of the conceptual framework of the article was the need to show the relationship between understanding concepts and teaching using English as the instruction language or using English and Spanish. The article's theoretical foundation incorporates bilingualism theories, where teachers value and incorporate two teaching languages. Bilingual teaching helps students gain the proficiency needed for cognitive development.
The author conducted the research at a private international bilingual learning institution in Bogotá. Madriñan (2014) selected kindergarten students aged four and six years as the participants. The selection criteria entailed exposure to English as a second language. The participants were Colombians with little to no exposure to the English language while preparing for elementary school. Additionally, at least one of their parents was conversant in English. The participants only knew some English words, like counting and colors. Nonetheless, the teacher used Spanish and English during their first school year. These students' details helped evaluate the article's goal of whether teaching using the first and second language enhanced learning more than when using the second language alone.
The author used an action research methodology and qualitative data collection methods. The author demonstrated the benefits of using the second and native languages concurrently in bilingual schools. The research question asked whether using the first language supports learning in a second language classroom to enhance kindergarteners' comprehension in their first school year (Madriñan, 2014). The first language is the learners' native or mother tongue (Spanish), while the second is the newly acquired language (English). The author failed to provide sources of the used protocol and questionnaires. Nevertheless, the action research methodology matches the author's research question well. The methodology tackled global school problems, including the need to give instructions using two languages. The study's limitations are delineated since the author used a short timeframe of six months, which can inte...
Updated on
Get the Whole Paper!
Not exactly what you need?
Do you need a custom essay? Order right now:

You Might Also Like Other Topics Related to language essays:

HIRE A WRITER FROM $11.95 / PAGE
ORDER WITH 15% DISCOUNT!